Matoli's Pizza & Subs

Samuel Christiansen

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

Awesome food! Great locally owned establishment - ordered regular and deep dish pizza as well as salad and desserts - all delicious. Enjoyed talked to the owner about his business and history - would recommend this place to anyone:

gordon rainey

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

When you walk into this time honored establishment your senses are treated to a level of authenticity that is usually found in a North East Italian neighborhood where the classics were perfected 165 years ago. My entire experience start to finish was a delight. From the genuinely sincere matriarch that took my order on the phone, to the polite pizza master in training busy boxing 6 pies to be delivered letting me know my order was about 6 minutes out, and finally my last contact was with the artisan himself, that when asked informed me he’d been making these pizzas for 73 years. I must bring up the glorious smells again coming from that oven that’s been producing these treasures for the last 25 years in this very spot. This is a zero frills take out joint steeped in history that I happened to stumble across a few blocks from my rental. I tend to order spaghetti and meatballs and a small version of the houses deluxe pie, here called the works. The spaghetti could feed two easily with the bonus two slices of pizza each on the side. If you are anywhere near Hernando Beach go there you won’t be disappointed.💥 🏆💥

Diana Simao

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

One of the best pizza places we have been to in a long time! We ordered deep dish pizzas and they are truly deep dish, not being skimpy with the toppings. They were absolutely delicious! The eggplant parm was also so good and could've fed 3 people. You can tell the owner takes pride in what he does and the food he makes. It was a joy talking to him.

Madison Gould

5 out of 5 stars★★★★★

Such great pizza! The only place in the area with Chicago deep dish and it did not disappoint! The sauce has a really nice sweetness to it. We also got the Greek salad and it was huge! The garlic cheese bread is good as well! It’s only a grab and go place. Will definitely be back!

Philip Cusimano ll

3 out of 5 stars★★★☆☆

The deep dis pizza was good. The salad was delicious. The people there were very attentive and friendly. It's a take out setup. No dinning are. Maybe they will have it in the future.